For much of his nearly 5 years, The Monkster has had the classic Beagle tear stain problem. It probably wasn’t all that evident in the blog photos because I often edited to remove or at least reduce the stains, but they were always there. I tried most of the common remedies such as:
- switching to the single non-poultry protein variant of their regular food
- adding a splash of organic cider vinegar to his meals
- omega 3 supplement
- gentle topical applications using manufactured and natural DIY solutions to reduce any possible irritation
None of them made any substantial difference, and obviously the topical remedies weren’t popular with a highly suspicious boy who believes the world is out to get him! Eventually I concluded that it would better just to accept it, as he was in all other respects in perfect shape. However, about a couple of weeks ago I realized that I wasn’t having to doctor any of his photos any more. I took a good look at the boy himself and the tear stains had indeed gone; occasionally there’d be a bit bit of gunk in the corner of one or other of his eyes after a nap, but the tearing really had stopped. The only change I’d made in that timeframe was to try out a candidate replacement food, and then only as a partial rather than a complete substitution.
The food change had been completely unrelated to my attempts to fix his tear staining; instead the goal had been to develop a shortlist of foods I could switch to if his staple food brand suddenly went down in quality. That’s something I’ve seen a few times in recent years. The pattern is always the same: a previously respected independent brand gets taken over by a big corporate, and then maybe six months later or so, the packaging changes and with that, the food itself appears changed. Maybe it’s a different color, or shape or consistency; when I scan through the dog-food related forums and groups I monitor, I see reports that some dogs who consume that brand and have done so for some time, are suddenly having issues. Examining the packaging typically reveals subtle changes to the wording and sometimes, but not always, changes to the listed ingredients.
Regardless, a couple of months ago I found a well-regarded cold-pressed food that looked like it could be a fallback if something were to happen to their current, also well-regarded cold pressed high meat content food. I ordered a bag, and began substituting it into their daily meals (70% current stuff, 30% new stuff by weight) to test it. I should point out that both foods have around the same calorie levels by weight, and as they’re both “complete”, there should be minimal risk of any nutritional deficits or excesses. I took notice of any changes in poops and such; Monkey started pooping a bit less (I was using fewer poo bags each day) and Daisy stopped having the occasional sloppy poop. Over the same period, both Susan and I commented that Monkey was being a bit more mischievous. It seemed his energy levels had been upped a little – though I hadn’t considered them in any way lacking prior to this – and of course more recently I noticed that his tear staining has ceased. Other than ever so slightly better poop consistency, there were no changes in Daisy.
Obviously nothing about this is even remotely scientific. I haven’t tried stopping the partial supplementation of their food to see if the changes reverse, and I have no plans to switch the pups completely over to this new food in the foreseeable future. However, the timing of the improvements in Monkey is hard to ignore; I intend to keep them on this mixture going forward as it seems to be working so well for them. While I won’t mention the brands involved (there’d be little point as so many brands seem to be changing recipes and/or quality these days), I find it interesting that it’s the mixing that seems to have brought the benefits, and for what it’s worth the new food’s primary protein source is chicken! In many internet dog groups chicken is the go-to villain, always to be avoided and eliminated from a diet (despite being a rather good natural source of taurine).
Anyway, I’ve recorded these things as much for myself as for anyone who might land on the blog, and as usual I’ll finish with a serving of photos of Monkey and Daisy on those precious days when it wasn’t raining. Or at least wasn’t raining that much. I mean, we’re in autumn now and this is Scotland :)

When we’re playing fetch, Monkey uses his rubber lobber and Daisy gets her orange tennis ball – them’s the rules!

Except that the new, mischief-enhanced Monkey 2.0 sometimes goes for the nice bright tennis ball instead!

Daisy is more than capable of getting her ball back of course!

Yeah, that’s how it should be!

But punishment must still be metered out for the boy who nicked the ball in the first place!

Clearly the change in food has not made Daisy any taller, or Monkey any shorter


























